“Get off your lazy butt,” she whispered
“I’m not lazy,” he said
defensively. “I’m a creative writing professor, I frickin‘ cross out adverbs all day long! It’s hard work!” He set his coke can gently on the coffee table. “Especially adverbs modifying verbs of attribution,” he muttered woodenly.
She rolled her eyes and barked
back, “All the bestsellers use adverbs of attribution, but what do they know! You’re the unpublished expert.”
Attribution adverbs, such as, “he said flatly,” are fine, in my humble and yet infallible opinion (imhayio), as long as they’re not omniscient-viewpoint things (words arising from an all-knowing perspective).
Attribution adverbs need to be the viewpoint character’s interpretation of something that was spoken.
Ask yourself, “is my viewpoint character coming up with this adverb, or is it me?”
Here’s what I mean…
Example of a decent attribution adverb from the vp character’s perspective:
“‘I love to be brutalized,’ he squeals jokingly. Or is he serious? With that lampshade on his head, I’m not sure.”
The viewpoint character is telling the reader how she interprets the guy’s words. The fact that she doubts her initial interpretation after she tells you that he was joking, makes this clear, I think.
Now here’s a hack’s “god-like” omniscient adverb in the same setting:
“‘I love to be brutalized,’ he says jokingly, though I’m just stupid enough to think he’s serious.”
Note that it’s a third-party, the all-knowing author, who has informed the reader that the guy is joking. The vp character thinks he’s serious, so she couldn’t have done it.
The viewpoint character is ready to bare her soul to the reader, but an all-knowing voice jumps in with an omniscient adverb and puts distance between them.
Avoiding omniscient adverbs is especially important in young adult work where many authors write from the limited viewpoint of a first-person character’s perspective (first person narrative) in present tense. Here’s an example…
I stumble on the rolling deck. It’s icy, 2:00 AM. I’m shaking. “Joseph, I know she’s here. I smell that stupid perfume.” My brother’s pistol is cold in my palm. Don’t jam again.
In first person narrative, present tense, it’s as if the vp character were telling the story word-for-word in real-time. Notice that the vp character is unaware of things she couldn’t logically know.
But here’s the point I wanted to make: if you’re aware that attribution adverbs (in the first person, present tense narrative, at least) should be provided by the viewpoint character and not by the author, the knowledge frees you to use these taboo things… to express the vp character’s emotion and her interpretation of other’s emotions.
Emotions are the key to most things in fiction writing, I believe.
Ultimately, if a writing professor were to cross your adverb out, you could say to yourself, “This is the way my viewpoint character told me the story. She’s not as well-educated as I am. If I cheated on her behalf, and made her sound like a university professor, I’d be hiding the truth of who she is.”
Writing as if you are “channeling” the vp character frees you from the university dogma, “Don’t use adverbs of attribution,” and its unspoken corollary, “always feel self-conscious about your writing voice.”
When the dear professor does this: “‘No!’ she said
Say to yourself, “The vp character said, ‘flatly,’ I didn’t.”
If this starts a discussion that finally brings your professor to denigrate authors such as Suzanne Collins, his negativity reflects denial of how infinitely more difficult and worthwhile it is to create a riveting story with living characters than to obsess over inbred, outdated writing rules that are being abandoned faster than creative writing classes.
I say, use adverbs whenever your viewpoint character feels them.
Never doubt the voice of your viewpoint character. Don’t think too much about your own writing voice. For the most part, it’s not you, it’s the viewpoint character doing the writing.
M. Talmage Moorehead